Editorial Policy

1. Purpose and general principles

This policy governs the handling of manuscripts disseminated before submission to EJERE as preprints in the technical sense, working papers, technical reports, or through other forms of preliminary dissemination. It also applies to manuscripts that overlap with related publications or research outputs by the same authors (prior publication).

EJERE applies the principles of transparency, research integrity, version traceability, originality of contribution, and proportional editorial assessment. Decisions are made on a case-by-case basis, taking into account the nature and purpose of earlier versions, the extent and scientific significance of any overlap, and the adequacy and completeness of the disclosure provided by the authors (see Attachment 1).

To support authors throughout the submission and peer-review process, the Journal’s Editorial Office:

  • publishes and regularly updates the criteria used to assess the suitability of repositories for preprint deposit (see Section 2.3);
  • interprets the policy in cases not expressly covered and may request additional documentation from authors;
  • promotes alignment with COPE guidance and international editorial best practices;
  • reviews the policy periodically in consultation with the Editorial Board and the Scientific Board.

1.1 Definitions

Preprint: a version of a manuscript made publicly available, usually through deposit in a repository, before completion of journal peer review.

Working paper: a research document disseminated in preliminary form, often within an institutional or disciplinary series, that may undergo subsequent revision.

Technical report: a technical, institutional, evaluation, or regulatory report documenting methods, activities, data, or findings for professional, administrative, or research purposes.

Postprint or Accepted Manuscript: the version of a manuscript accepted after peer review, including the revisions requested, but not yet typeset by the publisher.

Version of Record (VoR): the final, official, published version of the article.

Prior publication: any previous public dissemination of content relevant to the submitted manuscript, irrespective of format or venue.

Duplicate publication: the publication or proposed publication of work that is identical or substantially identical in purpose and findings to previously published work, without a distinct and justified purpose, the necessary permissions, and adequate disclosure.

Redundant publication: a publication that substantially overlaps with earlier work in data, questions, analyses, findings, or conclusions, without a clearly identifiable original contribution.

Salami publication: the artificial fragmentation of a single project into multiple articles that, when considered separately, do not present a sufficiently independent scientific question or a substantial informational contribution.

 

2. Eligibility of previously disseminated manuscripts

2.1 General principle

Previous dissemination of a manuscript as a preprint, working paper, or technical report does not, in itself, constitute grounds for exclusion or prior publication incompatible with subsequent publication in EJERE.

2.2 Conditions and disclosure

At submission, authors must disclose every relevant earlier version, specifying the platform or dissemination venue, DOI or URL, date of deposit or publication, and status of the version (see Attachment 1).

Authors must also provide:

  • a concise and verifiable description of the differences between each earlier version and the submitted manuscript;
  • an explanation of the added value of the submitted version, including where that value derives from the theoretical, methodological, analytical, or interpretative consolidation of the work;
  • a chronology of the principal revisions;
  • details of related publications, manuscripts under consideration, and other research outputs, together with a description of any overlap.

Authors may update a preprint during the editorial process, provided that the repository preserves the version history and that any substantial change is promptly reported to EJERE. The preprint must not present editorial decisions that have not yet been made as final, nor may it incorporate confidential reviewer comments without permission.

EJERE assesses the significance of the differences and the added value on a case-by-case basis. Disclosure does not automatically lead to acceptance: the Journal’s Editorial Office retains full discretion to assess the originality, relevance, quality, and fit of the contribution with the journal’s aims and scope.

2.3 Suitable repositories and document status

The mere online availability of a manuscript is not sufficient for it to qualify either as a preprint or as a prior publication. Its status is determined by the nature of the document, the way in which it is presented, and the features of the platform on which it is deposited.

As regard preprint and other similar documents, EdArXiv, SocArXiv, OSF, arXiv, PsyArXiv, medRxiv, bioRxiv, and equivalent platforms are generally considered suitable where they:

  • clearly identify the deposited manuscript as a preprint, that is, as a document that has not yet undergone journal peer review;
  • provide a persistent identifier, preserve the version history, and clearly distinguish peer-reviewed from non-peer-reviewed content;
  • make their moderation, withdrawal, and correction procedures transparent.

Working papers and technical reports disseminated through institutional series or official websites are assessed according to their function, degree of editorial formalisation, and relationship to the submitted manuscript, even where the platform does not operate as a preprint repository in the strict sense.

 

3. Editorial handling and peer review

Manuscripts associated with a preprint follow the same editorial and peer-review procedures as other submissions. The existence of a preprint is not, in itself, treated as either favourable or unfavourable. EJERE recognises that posting a preprint may reduce the effectiveness of anonymity in double-anonymous peer review; this does not automatically make the manuscript ineligible.

EJERE may use similarity-checking tools to support editorial assessment. No percentage threshold or other automated indicator replaces editorial judgement. The substantive assessment, conducted by the Editorial Board or staff expressly appointed by the journal, considers the dataset, research questions and purpose, design, analyses, findings, conclusions, images, and text as a whole. It also distinguishes problematic repetition from legitimate overlap, such as appropriately referenced standard methodological descriptions.

 

4. Transparency, traceability, and information for readers

EJERE identifies the existence of the preprint and its persistent identifier in the Version of Record, enabling readers to reconstruct the editorial history of the contribution.

Once available, the VoR should be used when citing the article. EJERE encourages bidirectional links, distinct DOIs, and preservation of the version history. Following publication, where permitted by the repository, authors must update the preprint record by adding the full citation and a link to the VoR.

 

5. Duplicate publication and authorised secondary publication

Simultaneous submission of the same manuscript to EJERE and another journal is prohibited. Duplicate publication, as defined in Section 1.1, is incompatible with publication in EJERE.

Forms of secondary publication that pursue a clear scientific or public purpose, are authorised in advance where necessary, and are fully transparent do not constitute duplicate publication. These may include:

  • authorised secondary publication, including a translation intended for a different readership, with the consent of the editors concerned, a clear indication in the title or a note, a full citation of the primary publication, and faithful content;
  • republication, expressly identified as such, of a historical contribution or one of particular relevance to the journal’s community;
  • a full article following an abstract, poster, conference presentation, letter, or preliminary report, provided that the preliminary nature of the first output and the relationship between the versions are disclosed;
  • a scientific article derived from a previously public institutional, technical, evaluation, or regulatory report, where the new text meets the requirements of scholarly communication, provides adequate further development, and clearly acknowledges the source;
  • other forms of republication required by law or by substantial accessibility and dissemination needs, provided that rights, permissions, and transparency requirements are met.

Before admitting a secondary publication, the Journal’s Editorial Office verifies:

  • the existence of a distinct and justified purpose;
  • the necessary permissions and compatibility of rights;
  • the completeness of the authors’ disclosure;
  • a visible reference to the primary publication;
  • the absence of a risk that findings will be counted twice;
  • clear labelling of the secondary nature of the contribution.

Example

A research team conducts a study of 1,500 students to examine the effectiveness of different approaches to teaching Italian. The researchers publish an initial article reporting the study’s findings, analyses, and conclusions. They subsequently submit a second article to another journal using the same sample, variables, analyses, and findings, changing only the title, structure, and some wording, without disclosing the earlier publication.

The second submission constitutes duplicate publication because it presents a substantially published contribution as new, without disclosure or an editorial justification for republication.

By contrast, a full article developed from a conference presentation or long abstract does not constitute duplicate publication, provided that the earlier output is not equivalent to a full article, the relationship between the versions is disclosed, and any applicable conference-proceedings rules are observed.

 

6. Redundant publication

EJERE assesses possible redundant publication on a case-by-case basis. Reuse of the same dataset or research programme does not automatically make a manuscript a redundant publication.

A manuscript may be considered for publication where it presents a distinct research question, a clearly identifiable original contribution, independent analyses or interpretations, and adequate and complete disclosure of all related work.

In its assessment, EJERE considers in particular what readers learn from the new article that is not already available, whether the overlap is necessary and proportionate, and whether the new contribution can be understood and assessed independently without obscuring its relationship to earlier work.

Example

A research team conducts a study of 2,000 students to examine the relationship between achievement in English and students’ socioeconomic and cultural background. Following an initial article on this relationship, the team publishes a second article using the same sample, indicators, and substantially the same analysis, reproducing the same findings with a different graphical presentation but without new analyses, interpretations, or evidence.

The second publication is redundant because it repeats previously published findings without a sufficiently independent scientific contribution. Redundancy is not determined by reuse of the dataset, but by substantial repetition of content and findings without a genuine addition to knowledge.

 

7. Salami publication

EJERE assesses potential salami publication on a case-by-case basis, distinguishing artificial fragmentation from the scientifically justified publication of independent contributions arising from the same project. Separate publication is acceptable where each article addresses a distinct question, requires an appropriate analytical approach, and makes a substantial and independent contribution.

In identifying salami publication, EJERE considers, among other indicators: nearly identical questions; largely overlapping descriptions and samples; analyses that should be integrated to support the same conclusions; findings that are incomplete when read separately; insufficient cross-referencing; and the absence of a scientific justification for separation.

Applied example

In a study of the relationship between mathematics achievement and mathematics self-efficacy, it may be appropriate to publish separately: (a) the full validation of a new scale for measuring mathematics self-efficacy; and (b) an analysis of the association between self-efficacy and mathematics achievement, provided that each article has an independent question, theoretical framework, and contribution.

At the opposite, it would not be appropriate to divide the validation into separate articles devoted, for example, to the Rasch model and concurrent validity if both analyses serve the same validation objective and neither article provides a sufficiently independent scientific contribution on its own.

Each article must include the analyses required to answer its research questions fully. Fragmenting a study into multiple articles that, even when explicitly cross-referenced, do not individually offer an original and independent contribution constitutes salami publication and is incompatible with publication in EJERE.

 

8. Omissions, requests for clarification, and editorial decisions

Where related versions or publications have been omitted, declarations are inaccurate, or information is insufficient, the Journal’s Editorial Office may suspend the editorial process, request copies and clarification, consult the editorial offices concerned, refer the matter for internal ethics review, or reject the manuscript. If the issue emerges after publication, EJERE takes corrective action appropriate to the seriousness of the case and the applicable editorial best practices.

 

9. Final provisions

Disclosure forms, editorial checklists, communication templates, and author instructions form an integral part of this policy. EJERE publishes the policy on its website and reviews it periodically in light of developments in international editorial standards.